Skip to main content

MasterChef Australia S13E05 - The second elimination

 Some of you are complaining that I have not actually ranted enough for a blog with the word “rant” in its name. Well, now you are getting a rant because I am extremely pissed with Episode 5.

The contestants enter the kitchen wearing black aprons – another elimination? WTF? What is the sense of 2 back to back eliminations in the 2nd and 3rd cooks of the season? Even last year, they had one opening cook, then a team challenge, then another immunity challenge and then an elimination. The contestants need some time to acclimatize and bring their best – not to mention that the judges themselves say that the winner is rarely the best cook on the first day, you have to grow and learn over time. But now, the contestants are expected to study hard, practice, grow by leaps and bounds in *2 days*. Why not just have 24 episodes and get this season over with?

I understand the producers are clearly avoiding team challenges, but surely if so many other sports / entertainment events, other TV shows and movies can manage bio bubbles, so can MasterChef.  Why screw up the entire premise of the show?

There are a bunch of plinths with black tins on them – each with a union jack. The contestants are wondering what is happening, and the sadistic judges very giddily tell them that this is another elimination and another one of them has gone through all this trouble to learn nothing from this experience and will get nothing more than a couple of episodes to totally change their life.

On this somber note, Mel is particularly excited to announce that it is superstar week. Like read the room, woman!

First of all, why is this happening so early in the competition? Maybe get the contestants to meet some low profile Aussie chefs, learn from them and improve before pulling out the big guns?  Secondly, why start such a motivational week with an elimination?

Mel introduces the guest chef – leaving nothing to suspense and everyone immediately knows its Nigella. This year the chef’s will be joining via telepresence – and will not actually walk around and meet the contestants. Or prepare or present their own dishes. So this is totally not like watching Nigella on TV – this is a deeply personalized experience okay? Okay?!

The totally unnecessary elimination is going to happen in 2 rounds – the first round is a taste test. The tins on the plinths have flavored biscuits on them and the contestants have to identify as many as they can.  Bottom five go to second round.

Nigella says she feels bad that she is party to this travesty of crushing the dreams of one wide eyed contestant – but for some reason she is smiling through it.

Linda is stoked (why??) and Yo yo is thrilled (again, why??). Yo yo says this is going to be super difficult, but she’s excited and expressing it with a Captain Holt-like command of emotions.

Tommy says tasting is his strength. Conor has an excellent wine palate – and is doubting everything he knows. Super ghissu Tom is panicking. Brent had a couple of mints in his mouth – and now everything tastes like peppermint. This is going to end well.

Andy doesn’t care about the challenge and is flirting with Nigella. On brand for Andy, he has not grasped the concept of virtual presence. He genuinely tries to give Nigella a biscuit – somehow expecting her right boob to take it from his hands. Pervert! One more addition to the many cringe-y moments we are expect on this show.

The scores come in – Linda and Tommy have top scored with 15/18. Trust the Asians to top something you can prep for eh?

Conor has identified only 4 elements lol. Brent, Maja and Yoyo have all identified 10 and are next to join him. There is a sudden death biscuit-off between Dan and Tom (both have 11 correct answers) – which Tom loses and ends up in the bottom five.

Round 2 is a pressure test which is not a real pressure test – because Nigella has written an eloquent description of a dish which the contestants have to decipher and cook. I do not approve of this challenge in general – what is this a test of, reading comprehension? – and specifically, because of the name which should not be “Pressure test” but “Sadistic Dick move”.

It is particularly surprising that the producers have decided to bring Nigella on for such a shit challenge – and basically made her a hated person in the kitchen immediately – when normally Nigella coming is a very positive, fun experience for all.

The cooks have 90 minutes to understand Nigella’s description of the dish and make it.

This is looking really bad for Brent – he is struggling to understand the flowery language and this is not even a proper recipe. If he gets eliminated because of this – I will throw my TV out of window and possibly burn a few pieces of furniture.

Tom is super anxious despite being a strong dessert cook, Conor is struggling, Maja seems to have figured this out as has Yo Yo.

Turns out they have to make a sponge cake with rhubarb and a torched meringue. The hyper eloquent description for a sponge cake with rhubarb seems totally pointless.

The contestants have a sheet with Nigella’s write-up which has super important information like “She positively exults in this dish” – Thanks! That totally helps me with how to make this. Said no one.

This is increasingly reminding me of the worst idea from last season i.e. twist week which saw a crowd favourite Amina go home because of a hare-brained idea of a dessert based pressure test without a recipe. It was so bad that the normally positive Reynold was also pissed and basically told the judges they had no clue what they were talking about saying that desserts need proper times and proportions – it’s not an intuition thing.

Coming back to this episode – Phew! Brent has figured out it is sponge cake a good 5-6 mins after everyone else. This is particularly good news for my TV and assorted pieces of furniture. 

Tom is giving serious terminator vibes and seems to be going well.

Mel asks everyone on the gantry to cheer for their idiotic idea. I’m sure all contestants are hoping that a giant pile of cowdung appears spontaneously on top of the judges while they cheer half-heartedly.

Okay, turns out, there are some instructions in the write-up – now this is even more stupid. Might as well have given the whole recipe.

Just as the contestants seem to be going well – another stupid idea that makes me question why I watch this show. Nigella now shows up on screen and asks them to make a cold custard. Firstly, this is a garbage challenge, on top of that you have people with no recipes, on top of that there is an elimination going on – this kind of ‘twist’ is not only illogical and sadistic – I don’t see what exactly they are testing here. How you deal with an asshole, whimsical boss doesn’t seem to the kind of quality you want to send someone home for.

Conor is rightly pissed, Yo yo is less visibly pissed because she had her cook planned out. Thankfully Brent knows how to make an anglaise.

The contestants have figured the components but with no times for cooking they have to rely on phrasing like “When the cakes are cooked” and “When rhubarb has emerged tender and holding shape” which totally do not help at all.

Brent has blazed through his anglaise and caught up. Conor seems to be using some different recipe for the anglaise.

Yo yo has assumed Poh position i.e. staring at the oven in despair. She’s frazzled because of the last minute addition of the anglaise. She finally gets it done but now her rhubarbs are waaaay overdone. She gets another batch on in the last 20 mins, but in the process overcooks her cake.  Then her rhubarbs emerge undercooked – she cannot get a break!

Nigella says she has her fingers crossed for the contestants – while I have fingers crossed for Nigella and what the contestants are going to do if they ever meet her. Somehow, MaasterChef Australia has managed to take the most popular, loved chef in the world and make everyone hate her.

Mel has the nerve to say that she is finding this so stressful – like her future career depends on an idiotic decision taken by a bunch of sadistic judges. Total let them eat make cake moment.

Nigella says she can’t believe everyone got a cake up – presumably because she expected people to just leave the kitchen in disgust seeing the stupidity of the challenge.

Mel says what a tough challenge – no shit Sherlock. They all thank Nigella for her beautiful (and useless) description of the cake. And also thank her for watching over the contestants – from 30 feet away on a small screen….. which was a total value add for the contestants, who didn’t exchange one single word of conversation with her and this was totally not like watching a youtube video.   

Sigh – my will to continue is breaking so let’s get over with this dumpster fire of an episode.

Here is the tasting:

Brent’s cake first. I (and my TV) are thrilled to tell you that he seems to have done a great job and seems safe.

Mel gives some bullshit about how ‘this is what the pressure test is about – listening to the expert and taking what you can’ NO ITS NOT!  IT’S READING A RECIPE AND FOLLOWING IT AND MAKING A DISH OUTSIDE YOUR USUAL AUKAAT!

Conor’s cake is dense, meringue is grainy.  This might be tough.

Andy’s expert comment on Maja’s cake is that it has a “beautiful size” – I mean how hard is it to at least try to sound knowledgeable about a freaking sponge cake. But it’s good and she seems safe.

Tom’s cake has some elements which are perfect like the meringue, the rhubarb and the anglaise, but part of the cake is too moist as he’s added the rhubarb juice which had caused the cake to sink.

Yo Yo’s dish as expected is not good at all. Almost everything is not perfectly done.

Andy sugarcoats this garbage challenge – really tricky, handled with strength and good humour. I guess he spent most of the time in the cook hitting on Screen Nigella because none of the contestants showed ‘good humour’ – they were all super nervous and pissed and stressed because they couldn’t call out the idiocy of this challenge on national TV.

This season, the judges has started this thing of telling everyone who is safe first and the person left out has been eliminated. Doesn’t make sense as everyone is happy and clapping at being safe – and then you turn to the person eliminated and say “Oh right, you are still here. Whoops, your dreams are fucked lol, go home now”

Not super surprising, but Brent, Tom and Maja are safe. It comes down to Conor and Yo Yo – and Conor survives because his rhubarbs were well cooked.

Yo Yo is no nonsense – says she not sad about leaving the kitchen (because fuck this show and fuck this non-challenge to throw her out), but she is sad about leaving the guys. She can’t get out of the kitchen fast enough and especially tries to snub the judges – who, beacons of self-awareness that they are, force her to acknowledge them. 

Let’s hope the next episode is less of a clusterfuck than this one.

Sigh, see you for Episode 6.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Introductory post aka What the hell is this and what to expect?

MasterChef Australia has returned to the air for its thirteenth season. I have decided to do something that I’ve wanted to for a long time - write in way too much detail about this show I tend to get to get too invested in for a normal person. Funny / satirical reviews of Masterchef Australia are not a new thing – there are hundreds of twitter accounts dedicated to this and several popular websites and blogs as well. My two favourites are Michelle Rennex (a culture writer at Junkee who writes on a lot more than just Masterchef ) and Ben Pobjie (who writes not just some super funny articles, but also some great poems on his website).   Since I am nowhere close to them in writing talent, I felt I should try do the same thing they do. Which is of course the totally normal, logical thing to do. That said - I don’t intend to make a clone of what they do, but you might see some similarities as some of my fandom might creep into my writing. I intend to post reviews as the week goes on

MasterChef Australia - S13E03 - The first challenge for the top 24

 Okay so here we go – now that all the hyper-confident idiots who couldn’t really cook very well have been tossed, we are good to start with the actual competition. The judges inform the top 24 that they are the top 24 – which is totally new information for all present. Jock seems the most excited person in the room as he talks up the top 24 and the competition, no one reacts – so he yells himself and claps. About five minutes later, Mel tries the same thing – but most people have learnt that the best way to get through this competition to simply not take any of the judges seriously. The first challenge is to be a mystery box. The judges build some suspense that the participants don’t know who has set the mystery box – and then reveal it has been set by Emilia – the winner of S12. This for good reason gets the participants super excited. But some seem surprised – I can understand why that might be so -   because the previous winner coming for the first challenge of the new season

MasterChef Australia S13E01 - The Auditions

 The auditions have always been the most boring part of Masterchef for me – and this year was no exception. In fact the only reason I even watched it was to be able to write this post. As usual we start with a ton of spoilers that make this episode totally unnecessary. We get in depth views from Elise and Therese (I wonder if they will be eliminated and sent home in this episode …hmm) as well as clips from future episodes which tell us pretty much everyone who makes it to the 24. Jock comes on to say that this year we are looking for spark – saying that it is all you need in the MasterChef kitchen. Which of course is patently false and you need a lot more than that to survive even one cook – y’know like cooking skills for instance. Andy says that the contestants learn every second in the competition and that makes this competition unique. This is a promising start – maybe he will continue to make sense through this season.   (Narrator: He won’t.) Mel says food is her love langu